Crucible

I think John Proctor is a "good puritan" because he portrays himself to be honest, speaks his mind. He also professes to believe in God, and it is important to him to have a good reputation to the town. Although he presents as a good puritan to the community, his actions are not so pure. We learn that he had an affair with Abigail, which indicates that he is not a good puritan morally. Instead of confessing his own bad behavior, he tries to go behind the scenes to cover up his sins.